Why Tums Work (Short Term)

Share this  —   Instagram    Facebook    Pinterest




We all recognize that big, booming voice from the TV commercials telling us, “Don’t change your lifestyle - go ahead, eat that whole pizza!”

The advertisements are clever. They understand that the only thing worse than experiencing heartburn is changing our lifestyle habits. Noooo! Anything but change!

So, they encourage us not to change, not to make healthier choices, but rather, to continue aggravating our reflux, because relief is just a chalky tablet away. Their mission is to sell a product, not to keep our best interest in mind.

These commercials not only encourage poor lifestyle habits, but they trick us into thinking that acid reflux is the problem, when in fact, reflux is a symptom of an underlying problem. It’s that underlying problem that needs to be addressed, but the more we pop those pills, the less we’re seeking real answers. 

To illustrate this point, consider this: 

Tums works by neutralizing stomach acid; however, heartburn occurs when the LES doesn’t close properly. So, unless Tums has hidden LES tightening capabilities, we’re missing something here. 

Let’s backtrack for a moment. What are Tums?

When it comes to antacids, there are generally two categories: Acid blockers and acid neutralizers. Tums is an acid neutralizer, meaning, it neutralizes the acid that is currently present in the GI tract. This accounts for why it may work in the moment but does not have long-lasting effects.

Tums’ main ingredient, calcium carbonate, is processed from pure limestone, and is the base that neutralizes acid. Tums also contains sucrose (sugar), as well as red and yellow food coloring.

Taking tums once in a while is unlikely to do much harm, however, if taken for long periods of time, it can cause excess calcium to build up in the blood, which can weaken bones and lead to kidney stones. Additionally, we know now that adequate stomach acid is needed for healthy digestion, so any time we take a neutralizer, we’re getting temporary relief, but setting ourselves up for long-term consequences.

What’s Causing the Symptoms?

Now let’s get back to treating the underlying causes. If taking Tums long-term is the only method of “treatment” you’re using for acid reflux, you could be doing yourself a great disservice. 

Somewhere in your body, there is an imbalance - too little stomach acid, a weak LES, perhaps an infection (such as Lyme, mold, or H-pylori), autoimmune disease, or other GI conditions (such as Candida or SIBO) that could be at the root of the reflux. 

Sometimes we just need relief now, and that’s okay! But it’s important to acknowledge patterns of relying on antacids and recognize that the underlying issue needs addressing. If you stepped on a thumbtack and had pain in your foot, you could take Advil all you want to help the pain go away, but at some point, you’ll need to find the thumbtack and remove it.

Healthier Methods of Relief

While you address the root cause, you’ll likely still have reflux from time to time and need some immediate relief. Consider some of these all-natural alternatives to Tums that may just do the trick!


Hiatal Health. Dr Barry strongly believed that just addressing symptoms was a short sighted way to think about health. Instead he focused all his work on root cause. He threw himself into the process of identifying the root causes of acid reflux and how to address them naturally. Our combination of all natural herbs targets the discomfort of heartburn, acid reflux, and indigestion that is frequently triggered by hiatal hernias or esophageal weakness. Dr. Barry searched for many years to find an acid reflux remedy that focused on strengthening the tissue weakness that allows for the condition. This unique formula has helped thousands of people on their journey toward digestive wellness.


Digestive enzymes (i.e. papaya enzymes). Our bodies naturally produce enzymes in the digestive process that help us break down various foods, however, sometimes we need a little extra support. Papaya contains papain which eases digestion. If reflux is aggravated by gas from undigested food, digestive enzymes can help.

Marshmallow lozenges. The leaf and root of marshmallow can help with pain, inflammation, and swelling, particularly in the mucous membranes along the GI and respiratory tracts. For this reason, marshmallow extracts have a soothing effect.

Chamomile. A nice cozy cup of chamomile tea after a long day has calming effects on our whole body, including the stomach. It does not neutralize stomach acid the way Tums does, however, it can reduce subsequent pain and irritation in the throat caused by reflux. 

Ginger. Ginger can be useful in instances where a large meal initiates reflux. Ginger reduces stomach contractions. This comes in handy to prevent acid from getting pushed back up in the wrong direction.

ACV or lemon juice. ACV and lemon juice are long-term remedies for acid reflux, as they increase the necessary stomach acid to keep the LES tight. However, some people find that consuming a little ACV and/or lemon juice mixed with water can help alleviate heartburn as it’s happening.

Baking soda. Baking soda is the ultimate base, neutralizing acid. Baking soda works the same as Tums to disarm acid, which can give you immediate relief. Dissolve 1/4 teaspoon in 8 oz of water, drink, and you’re all set.




Leave a comment